Economic process – like other world processes – has an immanent intelligibility consisting of primary relativities which can be applied to the coincidental secondary determinations which occur throughout time in a non-systematic manifold. Economic process is constituted by schemes of recurrence under the dominance of abstract principles and laws; nevertheless, the actual concrete workings of the economic schemes of recurrence are shot through and throughout time with indeterminancy. So, it is a fact that prediction is impossible in the general case, since the concrete patterns of events occurring throughout time are a non-systematic aggregate. Thus, the point-to-line and higher correspondences are based upon the indeterminacy of the relation between current surplus products and the ultimate later basic products that eventually exit the dynamic process and enter into the standard of living.
An event in an economic scheme of recurrence has a diverging series of conditions. Continue reading
In his book, FREEFALL (2009, Penguin Books), Joseph Eugene Stiglitz, a professor at Columbia University and a recipient of the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences (2001) and the John Bates Clark Medal (1979), states that economics is a predictive science. Now, one must distinguish between predicting a) planetary motion in its scheme of recurrence, and b) this afternoon’s weather vs. next month’s weather, or this afternoon’s prices and quantities vs. next year’s prices and quantities, all subject to to conditions diverging in space and time. Continue reading)
The Functional Macroeconomic Dynamics Collaborative
Website: Bernard Lonergan’s Functional Macroeconomic Dynamics
Brian C. Moyer, Director
Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA)
4600 Silver Hill Road
Washington, DC 20233
Dear Mr. Moyer,
Presently the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) publishes three general versions of the National Income and Product Accounts (NIPA).
- Gross Domestic Product, Current $
- Gross Domestic Income by Type of Income; National Income by Type of Income; and, National Income by Sector …; Current $)
- Gross Value Added by Sector; Current $)
Would it be possible for the BEA staff to develop a fourth which would be explanatory of the production-and-exchange process? Continue reading
There is required a shift of focus by academics from the concrete secondary determinations of prices and quantities in a non-systematic manifold to the immanent, abstract, primary relativities which may be applied to these secondary determinations to reach particular laws.
Paraphrasing [McShane, 1980, 127]: Taking into account past and (expected) future values does not constitute the creative key transition to Functional Macroeconomic Dynamics. Continue reading
The process is always the current, purely dynamic process. The analysis is purely functional, purely relational and explanatory analysis. The theory is general and universally applicable to concrete determinations in any Instance; The theory is a normative theory having a condition of equilibrium.
Our subheadings in this treatment are as follows:
- Always the Current Process:
- A Purely Dynamic Process Requiring a Dynamic Heuristic:
- A Purely Functional Analysis:
- A Purely Relational, Explanatory Analysis:
- A Theory, General and Universally Applicable to Concrete Determinations in Any Instance:
- A Normative Theory Having a Condition of Equilibrium:
Always the Current Process: Continue reading
New foundations for a new science of macroeconomics are grounded in
- a scientific, dynamic heuristic
- the technique of implicit definition
- precise, purely relational, analytical distinctions between fundamental terms representing functional flows of products and money
- the functional interrelations among these interdependent, mutually defining, explanatory functional flows